Butterfinger Cookies

These butterfinger cookies are a great way to use up leftover candy bars. Soft, chewy and butterfingery. These cookies are everything!

This is the story about my disastrous day and how these turned out to be my coping cookies.

Wednesday was the day and everything I touched broke. I am not even kidding. These cookies almost didn’t even make it.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (12)

Sometimes we just have one of those days. My friend, Stacey had hers the day before and to be honest it was much worse than mine. I pretty sure I jinxed myself when I went to bed Tuesday with plans to have a cooking extravaganza the following day. A non-stop cooking-and-baking-stay-in-my-sweats-and-not-shower-sort-of-deal. But when I realized my daughter needed her physical paperwork (so she could try out for volleyball) signed and that I would have to make a trip up to the school… that nixed any ideas of staying in my sweats. No big deal… a shower wasn’t the worst thing in the world.

So then while doing the dishes that afternoon, my (favorite) glass liquid measuring cup literally exploded right after I washed it and set it onto the towel to dry. And yes, I instagram’d it. We’re talking shards, big and teeny-tiny, of glass everywhere. It was so darn scary and minutes afterwards I could still hear the pieces crackling like hot embers would in a fire, in the garbage. It was the strangest thing! And I loved that measuring cup, so dumb I know… but I did. So naturally I had to clean all the broken glass fragments, sweep, vacuum, re-wash dishes and counters and pretty much anything in the vicinity.

With my day gone to hell in a hand-basket I thought that I would just make cookies. My daughter had her first volleyball tryout, I lost my beloved measuring cup… why not? So I grabbed the leftover bag of butterfingers and my camera and made cookies. The first batch was baking, they smelled to die for… and then all this popping and bursts of light was coming from my oven. I killed the heat, slowly opened the doors and noticed it was coming from the lower heating element. Long story short, the bottom baking element shorted out. But I was determined to make these cookies. So I finished them in the oven, with only the top element to heat it up. Fingers were crossed. It took a little longer than it should have and the bottoms weren’t necessarily crisp, but I wasn’t about to waist Butterfinger cookie dough. No way.

So I pretty much threw in the towel after that. Later I grabbed a book and a glass of wine and a cookie or three.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (010)

So enough about my horrendous day, let’s talk about these cookies. So incredibly simple. It’s just a soft, chewy cookie studded with big hunks of Butterfinger candy bars. Really you could do this with Snickers (which will be happening ASAP) or my kid’s favorite Take 5 bars. They are an excellent way to use up that Halloween candy or brighten a day spent cleaning up glass shards. (Trust me)

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (1)

Start by measuring the 2-1/4 cup flour, 1 teaspoon baking soda and 1 teaspoon kosher salt into a medium bowl.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (2)

Give it a gentle whisking to fluff and break up any heavy clumps.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (3)

Add 2 sticks, unsalted, room temperature butter into the bowl of your stand mixer.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (4)

Add 1 cup light brown sugar along with 1/2 cup granulated sugar.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (5)

Mix on low to medium-low speed until light and fluffy.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (6)

Add in a teaspoon of real vanilla extract…

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (7)

Add in one egg at a time, mixing and scraping down the sides of the bowl after each one.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (8)

Once combined, with the mixer on low, slowly add in the dry ingredients. Stop mixing just when they are combined. Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (1)

Grab 10 or so mini Butterfinger candy bars.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (2)

And give them a rough chop. I like big fat chunks in my cookies, but you could cut them smaller if you wish to do so.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (3)

Add the candy pieces into the mixer and mix until they are throughout the dough. I contemplated sitting down with the paddle-o-dough and finish it off.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (4)

I used a 2-tablespoon scoop and doled out the dough onto a lined cookie sheet.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (9)

Bake the Butterfinger cookies for 8 to 10 minutes or until the edges are slightly golden.

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (13)

After a few minutes of cooling on the pan, transfer the butterfinger cookies to a wire rack to cool.

I really love them the day after when the Butterfinger candy pieces have returned back to being their crispy-flaky-selves while suspended in all that delicious cookie goodness. Actually, all this talk about candy in cookies has me thinking I’ll just mosey on into the kitchen and have one with my morning cup of coffee.

My favorite candy bar in a cookie, I can’t believe I didn’t think of this sooner.

Happy Halloween!


Enjoy! And if you give this Butterfinger Cookies recipe a try, let me know! Snap a photo and tag me on twitter or instagram!

Butterfinger Cookies l SimplyScratch.com (11)

My cookbook Simply Scratch : 120 Wholesome Homemade Recipes Made Easy is now available! CLICK HERE for details and THANK YOU in advance!

Yield: about 2 dozen

Butterfinger Candy Bar Cookies

Butterfinger Candy Bar Cookies
Soft, chewy and butterfingery. A great way to use up leftover Halloween candy.
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 30 minutes
Total Time 45 minutes


  • 2-1/4 cups unbleached all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
  • 1 cup light brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 2 large eggs
  • 10 mini Butterfinger candy bars, chopped


  1. Preheat your oven to 350° and line two metal sheet pans with parchment or silicon liners.
  2. In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking soda and salt. Set aside.
  3. In the bowl of your stand mixer beat together the butter and both sugars until light and fluffy. Add in the vanilla and one egg at a time, mixing and scraping down the sides of the bowl after each egg.
  4. With the mixer on low, gradually add in the dry ingredients until just incorporated. Add in the chopped candy bars and mix until through the dough.
  5. Use a 2-tablespoon scoop and place rounded scoops of dough onto prepared pans. Bake for 8-10 minutes or until the edges of the cookies are lightly golden brown. Let cool on the pan for 5 minutes before transferring to a wire rack. Repeat with remaining dough.

[this post contains affiliate links.]

    Pin It

10 Responses to “Butterfinger Cookies”

  1. #
    Mia Sar — October 31, 2014 at 6:28 am

    each stick of butter, how much gram?

    • Laurie McNamara replied: — November 5th, 2014 @ 9:16 am

      I believe one stick is 113 grams. 🙂

  2. #
    Laura @ Raise Your Garden — October 31, 2014 at 7:51 am

    Butterfingers are the best candy ever bar none. But in cookie form? What, my head in spinning. Laughed at your v-ball story. My husband is a volleyball coach and yes, that paperwork, Ha, is so important. He might be going to states this year with his team they are so good. But sports are beyond my understanding, would rather make cookies!!

    • Laurie McNamara replied: — November 5th, 2014 @ 9:17 am

      That’s awesome Laura! And I totally agree… butterfingers are the best! 🙂

  3. #
    Carol+at+Wild+Goose+Tea — October 31, 2014 at 11:45 am

    Gosh when you said everything you touched broke, I wasn’t expecting it to be literally and quite so dramatically. Geez the glass thing in your kitchen that is dang scary! But look at this lovely cookies–switching to the positive. Smiles—-

    • Laurie McNamara replied: — November 5th, 2014 @ 9:17 am

      Cookies have a way with making everything better 🙂

  4. #
    Just+Me — November 1, 2014 at 9:30 pm

    I had a pie plate explode like that several years ago. Earlier this year I took a casserole dish out of the cupboard and had two pieces. Sounds like pyrex has changed its formula and they are now more prone to breaking.:-(

    • Laurie McNamara replied: — November 5th, 2014 @ 9:19 am

      I’ve heard of glass/pyrex exploding but I kind of thought it was a myth or the whole cold pan/hot oven situation. But apparently it’s true and is pretty darn scary!

  5. #
    Jennie+@themessybakerblog — November 3, 2014 at 8:51 pm

    Bad days deserve cookies like these. They look perfectly gooey and amazing. RIP glass measuring cup.

  6. #
    Laurie McNamara — November 5, 2014 at 9:19 am

    So true… thanks Jennie! <3

Leave a Comment